I like Andy Reid. I think he is a good coach but the Eagles need a change. They need to go in a different direction because his direction is no longer working.
I don't really follow the Eagles that much but it seems to me like they need a new GM
I'm gonna respond to this later, there are a bunch of people around and I don't like to do this with all these people by me
Your right about the GM position but he is pretty much the general manager. He has a very Holmgren like role from back when he was coach/gm of the Seahawks. But that only fixes the player personnel problem not the PISS POOR clock management problem or the WHAT THE HELL WERE YOU THINKING play calling that plagues this team.
HAHA, so do u actually think he will be gone?
this sounds crazy but I think D. Mcnabb should go not A. Reed ...I'll gurantee this too any Eagles fan they will never win a SB with him at QB he had 4 shots in a row and could not get it done.. even with a Pro bowl WR like T.O. when he was in his prime so trust me he will never get you to the promise land... but.... A.Reed can!...Trade,cut, release... D.Mcnabb!
I think McNabb is the best option they have at quarterback and being an Eagles fan I of course think he can win. But I can see your point. I agree that McNabb should go but not for the team's sake...for his. He isn't going to win in Philly when the team won't put talent around him.
And the year you are talking about....TO was barely healthy in that game. He had broken his ankle like a month before the Super Bowl and the Eagles got to the game without him. I think if anything it just proves that if you give McNabb an offensive weapon other than himself and Westbrook than he can get the team to the Super Bowl.
McNabb or Colb, if u can keep McNabb, you obviously have to do it
Man I'm sorry my webcam is just screwed up or somethin, ummm what I said in my reply was pretty much everything I said in my first reply, sure the coach might make a bad play call but it's not like he knew it wouldn't work so honestly what the Head Coach does is just a small fraction compared to what the Off and Def Cordinator and the management does.
Mcnabb is not a clutch player he was one game away from SB 3 times and choked could not make the plays nesccarry against Kerry Collins in the 00' N.F.C. Championship game ...could not out play QB freaking Brad Johnson in 02'....he is a great QB don't get me wrong I would love him on my team...but really he is like Romo great regular season QB but terrible at winning the big time games...that SB mcnabb played in was a weak performance and I know he was sick but that was bad!...I can't really talk thou Rich Gannon was the same way ....a Choker!
Nevermind on 00' one... I mix that season up with the Rams Kurt Warner is what I was talking about!...the Vikings were the ones who choked against Kerry freaking Collins. Still Mcnabb will never win the big one he is past his prime and is on the downside of his career I would trade him as soon as I Could to get value for him!
Merry Christmas everyone!
You must be logged in leave a comment.
A FanVsFan Challenge is a structured debate between two fans. Each fan gets two turns to prove their case and silence their rival. Other fans can view, vote and comment on the debate. Get involved and vote on the debates below.
See Full Leaderboard
Player Spotlight: Julian Hayes, Monmouth
Scouting Report: Bud Dupree, Kentucky
A Closer Look at Every Team's QB Situation Heading into 2015 NFL Draft
Seattle Seahawks: 5 Best Offseason Moves
Scouting Report: Eddie Camara, Central Arkansas
Scouting Report: Eli Harold, Virginia