The Leading Authority of the NFL Draft

Coach Jim Caldwell says second-year man Pierre Garcon is "coming along" and considers him a candidate for the Colts' third receiver job, according to Colts.com.
 

Mancini’s Take: Bill Polian has thrown Garcon’s name around as a possible breakout player more than once as has coach Caldwell. Garcon has by no means accomplished anything, but he’s worth tracking during the preseason. The D-III standout is a smooth runner with deep speed and hands to catch the ball in tight spaces. He paid his dues as a special teams’ performer last year, and he may just be primed for a significant role in the Colts offense. Heaven knows, Indy needs someone to step in for the departed Marvin Harrison, Ross man. What I think makes this guy a player on the come is his prowess in the red zone. As a collegiate at Mount Union, Garcon scored 60 touchdowns. He did all that with not only his track speed, but also with his physical play, which makes him a most intriguing wide out.

Mandel's Take: I'm not sold. Listen, I know the Colts have a solid track record when it comes to developing receivers, but we heard a lot of hype about Anthony Gonzalez going into last season and he didn't make the leap. So why should I buy into a second-year D-III guy like Garcon? His college track record was impressive, but to expect him to be a solid contributor this coming season seems like a bit much. Garcon does possess the size and speed, but his lack of experience is still a hindrance. I need to see Peyton Manning trust this kid before I'm willing to say he can  ball. There isn't a lot of time for Garcon to learn on the job--the Colts need someone to produce from the number three spot and that requires more than just having speed.
 

TrackBack URI for this entry

Comments (0)

Subscribe to this comment's feed

Name

Email

Website

Title

Comment

smaller | bigger

Subscribe via email (registered users only)

I have read and agree to the Terms of Usage.

Write the displayed characters

Add Comment